Tip of the hat to my friend Yul Ejnes who tweeted this article – What Happens If Nothing Happens to Health Care?
Barring a political miracle, we're going to learn the cost of doing nothing—nothing significant to restrain health-care cost increases, nothing to prod the health-care system to produce more benefit for each dollar it takes, nothing to expand health-insurance coverage.
This, too, will be ugly and unpopular.
"Failure to enact health reform will result in increasing numbers of people without health insurance because fewer employers will offer it and many employees will not be able to pay the cost of plans that are available," predicts Stephen Zuckerman, a health economist at Washington's Urban Institute think tank.
"For people not offered employer coverage, many will not be able to get coverage due to pre-existing conditions that insurers won't cover or because premiums simply won't be affordable. Even people with coverage will find costs becoming a greater financial burden," he said.
And all of us—employers, workers and taxpayers—will spend ever more on health care.
We should have a legitimate discussion on the best methods to reach the most desirable results. Both political parties have failed us.
The Democrats have spent too much time adding pet projects and trying to keep various constituencies happy. The Republicans have failed to add creatively, preferring to gain political points for their opposition.
The Democrats have failed to tell the stories that will help the American people understand the problem. The Republicans have use disingenuous slogans.
The pollsters have not helped. They find that most Americans are happy with their health insurance. The pollsters ask the wrong question.
We need more stories about people losing insurance through no fault of their own. We need more stories about small businesses failing to grow because health care is so costly. We need stories about bankruptcies. We need stories about real income decreasing because the employee contribution to health insurance costs keeps rising. We need stories about Big Pharma increasing their prices faster than inflation. We need stories about the true costs of imaging studies and contrast those costs with the prices charged. We need stories about the varied deals that insurance companies make with hospitals. We need the American public to develop the sense of outrage about health care costs that many physicians have. Excellent health care need not be so expensive.
Now I do not love the Democratic bills. They have flaws. But they are generally better than the status quo. The status quo really is unacceptable.
I have no faith in our politicians developing a reasonable solution to this issue. I see no profiles in courage. I do see many self-aggrandizing talking heads playing issues for re-election purposes.
So I am caught in a quandary. I am supporting bills with flaws. But then all bills have flaws, and we must focus on whether the good exceeds the bad. I think it does.
Related posts:
Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.
6 Responses to We need health care reform
PeterW
February 4th, 2010 at 10:11 am
Of course the Democrats focused entirely on expanding insurance, without doing a thing about the main issue: cost control. Everyone can agree that "reform" is needed, but many many policies fall into that box and many of them are harmful.
PeterW
February 4th, 2010 at 10:12 am
I should add that of course expanding insurance only exacerbates the third party payer problem that leads to escalating costs. Europe and Japan started from a lower base but now have the same rate of cost inflation as us, thanks to the perverse incentives – if my boss is paying, I'll have filet mignon.
DB's Medical Rants » Blog Archive » We need health care reform | Health Blog
February 4th, 2010 at 12:25 pm
[...] Continue reading here: DB's Medical Rants » Blog Archive » We need health care reform [...]
DB's Medical Rants » Blog Archive » We need health care reform « Master Blog For USA
February 4th, 2010 at 3:25 pm
[...] Read this article: DB's Medical Rants » Blog Archive » We need health care reform [...]
Dr. Bob (FP)
February 4th, 2010 at 4:09 pm
None of the national level politicians (both D & R) have the courage to suggest things that result in real cost control. They can't do this without angering some group that contributes money. They can't cut costs without affecting some group's gravy train (Pharma, insurers, physicians, etc.) They don't think they can win votes if they tell people what they really need to hear (yes, the public is guilty of over-utilization too). I too am becoming cynical that any meaningful reform will happen on the national level. I think we'll have to tackle this on the state level.
Michael Kirsch, M.D.
February 4th, 2010 at 4:44 pm
I am not certain that the Democratic plan is really better than the status quo. I think their plan made significant inroads on expanding access, but failed in controlling costs. To accomplish the latter, various stakeholders would have to sacrifice income, careers and companies. Not surprisingly, there weren't too many volunteers. Hospitals and Pharma agreed at the outset to give back, but most of the players in the game zealously protected their parochial interests. My view is that medical overutilization should be attacked. Of source, an 'overutilized' test or treatment is someone else's income. No easy solution here. Get prepared for microreform.