Now this fits my definition of a great case – Cough, 102-Degree Fever, Lightheadedness
A few tidbits – then go read:
”She’s been like this for two weeks,” the mother began when the young physician entered the room. ”And no one can figure out why.” Her 21-year-old daughter had always been very healthy. She’d recently returned from a school trip to Africa, and she was fine throughout her month abroad. Even back at school she felt well until two Sundays ago, when she began to feel hot and sweaty. Just standing up made her lightheaded. A lengthy nap brought some relief but by the next day, she realized that she was feverish, so she went to the infirmary.
”I told them I thought it might be malaria,” the patient added softly. ”The teacher told us it was common where we were in Tanzania.” The infirmary nurse thought it was probably a flu. They’d seen several cases in the past few weeks at the college. But when the young woman didn’t get better over the next several days, a nurse referred her to an infectious-disease specialist in town. Maybe it was malaria. Since she had been in an area rife with this mosquito-borne illness, the specialist started her on a week of quinine and doxycycline to treat a likely case of malaria.
She took a full seven-day course, but the medicine didn’t help. Over the next few days she developed a cough so violent it made her vomit. She had abdominal pain that made even standing difficult. And she had terrible diarrhea. When she made yet another trip to the infirmary, they called an ambulance to take her to a hospital nearby. There she was given fluids, and blood was drawn and sent for tests. They told the patient she had mono. At that point, she was too sick to return to school, and her mother took her home to recover.
The internist knew that he needed help. He sought consultants until he made the correct diagnosis.
…I called Dr. Hammami with the news of the final diagnosis and asked why it had been missed by all the doctors the patient saw before arriving at his hospital. He thought for a moment before he answered. ”It’s difficult for a doctor to say, ‘I don’t know,”’ he said. ”The patient doesn’t want to hear it, and the doctor doesn’t want to say it. But in medicine you can’t know everything; you just have to know how to get the answer. I was certain the eosinophils would get us there.”
So go read the story and try to figure it out (I actually had the correct diagnosis very high in my differential). And applaud the internist for taking the time to think. Thinking takes time; insurers are loathe to pay for thinking; getting it right is more important than worrying about reimbursement.
Related posts:
Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.
8 Responses to An internist without an ego!
RGL
November 8th, 2004 at 11:19 am
A fascinating case.
I have been taught, whether in medicine or any other area, that the beginning of wisdom is when we say: I DON’T KNOW.
One reason I think most internists, perhaps even some ID specialists, would miss diagnosing this case is the minimal exposure we had in tropical medicine. Plus, we may never have seen a case in training or in practice.
Indeed, Dr. Hammani deserves a lot of credit for pursuing this case until its resolution. It’s never beneath us to seek help when we need it.
Steve Lucas
November 8th, 2004 at 5:46 pm
Another important factor was the collaboration of the family. We as patients can bring important contacts to help resolve a problem, plus the involvement helps the family to own the solution. This can be an asset in long term care and rehab.
Bernie Simon
November 8th, 2004 at 8:50 pm
OT link: Americans Mad and Angry a new web site devoted to documenting iatrogenic illness.
RGL
November 8th, 2004 at 9:42 pm
The other AMA Bernie is referring to reminds me of the old KKK designed to instill fear among Americans. It is another of those fringe groups with nothing good to say about medicine.
Invoking the IOM report issued in 1999 has become a bible among trial lawyers – a flawed study where a second look by another group from Harvard did not identify the so-called errors with thousands of deaths. That study has been discredited.
For this fringe group to say little has been done to minimize medical errors is arrant dishonesty. I can almost guess who are behind this sleazy website.
Steve Lucas
November 9th, 2004 at 5:00 am
Silly me, I thought the doctor acted in a professional manner by seeking solutions to a problem he could not answer. I don’t think too many American doctors see this type of case and being open to input was the object in seeking a solution. Yes it would have been nice to have caught the reason for the illness on the first visit, but guys, you can not know everything about everything.
Bernie Simon
November 9th, 2004 at 7:44 pm
Could we have a discussion of iatrogenic illness without getting bogged down in name calling? In-hospital infections and bedsores are real sources of morbidity and not figments of a malpractice lawyer’s imagination. And they are problems that could be simply addressed. Doctors, for one thing, could wash their hands more consistently.
From my limited experience, the people who are banging the drum on iatrogenic illness are the injured and families of the injured, just as the vaccine safety movement is run by the families of those harmed by vaccinations.
Modulator
November 11th, 2004 at 1:17 pm
Finding the Cure
Health care emulates lifeI called Dr. Hammami with the news of the final diagnosis and asked why it had been missed by all the doctors the patient saw before arriving at his hospital. He thought for a moment before he answered. ”It’s difficult for …
Scrappyboy
November 27th, 2004 at 7:49 pm
Not only are the comments by RJL tacky and unprofessional, they are also wrong. As an initial matter, I thought the “content and feel” of the other AMA website( http://www.americansmadandangry.org/ ) was honest and informative; anything but “sleazy.” Whether RJL accepts it or not, the fact is that iatrogenic illness and nosocomial infection are serious public safety problems. It’s my guess that if more physicians thought like Bernie Simon and less like RJL, these would not be as big of issues as they are today. Hey, doctors and other healthcare professionals are human, ok? Mistakes are made. Buck up; if your not part of the solution your part of the problem. End of story.