Dr. Friedman your analogy reveals some basic problems. IQ is Intelligence quotient: that is, educational age divided by chronological age, so if education increased for everyone IQ would remain at 100. And an IQ of 140 is 4 standard deviations above the mean, meaning, 99.99% are between 60 and 140, and half are above 140, making it 0.0005% are over 140.

And our food industry produces 8300 calories per day for every man woman and child in America (David Katz, MD, Yale Public Health) We need about 2200 on average.

I personally agree that the fat are getting fatter and that most everyone elses weight is only a bit higher but so our people’s height due to better nutrtion and that can cause a little higher weight plus we have more older people living longer and getting a little extra padding is normal.

also I seem to have gotten fatter despite weight watchers being a jogger for 10 years or more and eating only three meals a day being careful to keep caloiers down, contrary to popular belief, people like myself do not sit in front of the tv and gorge on chips and junk food all day long or dislike exercise, I have always exercised, it was not unusual for me to go for a two hour hike in the woods which around here are very hilly.

some times I would go for an hour walk during the week 2 or there days and long hikes on the week end, but that didn’t keep me or get me thin, in fact it may have contributed to be getting fatter.

the only epidemic I see is a dieting epidemic or food phobic or fat hatred epidemic, while they may say we eat more caloires per day than in the past (how do they know that do they moniter every single individual in the united states 24 hours a day 7 days a week 365 days a year?) and how do they know all the food being bought at the store is being eaten?

my cart is always full of “good and bad” foods each week but guess what many times I will cook a meal and end up not eating all of it because I got full and lost interest and guess who go the left overs? either the dog or the trash.

I don’t know how many times I only drank a half can of soda because I lost interest, or lost the craving for it and threw it out. I don’t save junk food when I lose interst it gets thrown out, some good foods I don’t save because it doesn’t taste good when reheated.

but foods that still taste pretty good get saved, but many times I end up throwing it out a few days later because I just don’t have a taste or craving for it. I don’t know how many times I would open a can of soup eat part of it and give the rest to the dog.

so how do they come to the conclusions we are all a bunch of food gorgers? because they see how fat we are getting, the food gorging is assumed, and we know what happens when we assume, because if you were not overeating you would not be fat. so it is a foregone conclusion, unfortunantly it is a myth or fallacy.

this scenario for my eating habits I am sure fit fat and thin people alike, my thin husband eats alot more junk food than I do, he is naturally thin, hasn’t a speck of fat on him except a small mid section that you don’t notice unless he is bending over, but other than that he is thin, yet the doctor said he should lose 30 pounds.

30 pounds!!!! do you know that if he did that he would dissapear if in fact the 30 pounds is actual fat and not muscle or water loss. 3 pounds of fat loss is a size, if he lost 30 pounds of fat (without losing muscles or water) he would lose 10 sizes, he would have no bottom or mid section. I don’t think there is 30 pounds of fat on him, he is muscular, because he lifts weights, and he loves long hikes and walks, and he works on a job where he is lifting and walking for hours on end.

so 30 pounds! give me a break. I explained to him some principles that is too lengthy here on why he should ignore the doctor (my hubby tried to go on a diet) and he stopped trying to diet.

thank goodness, dieting or restricting caloires (famine) makes you get fatter in the long run.

RR