Previous Entry | Main | Next Entry

September 07, 2002


More on 1 hour of exercise

Medpundit weighs in on the IOM report - An Hour a Day?!!!!. She finds the second day 'spin' debriefing from the Philadelphia paper. The spin:

Walk and take stairs whenever possible, advises Penny Kris-Etherton, a nutrition professor at Pennsylvania State University and a member of the committee that drafted the guide.

...

"It seems like a lot of time for very busy people, but remember, you have 16 hours every day to work with," said Kris-Etherton, who gets in her hour by walking for 15 minutes on a treadmill in the morning and again in the evening, and by walking and taking stairs during the day.

"We're not calling for an hour of formal exercise in the gym," she emphasized. "We're trying to encourage people to incorporate more physical activity in their daily lives so an hour doesn't seem so daunting."

I was taught early in life to say what I mean. Common parlance suggests that when recommends exercise, one means exercise above and beyond that achieved in daily activities. I believe that the report meant to sensationalize. However, if your recommendations seem unreasonable to even health conscious physicians, then you have missed your target. 'The road to hell is paved with good intentions.' I do not know if that fits here, but I did think it. The should more precisely say what they mean, and not sensationalize their reommendations.

I agree with more daily walking. I climb stairs all day and walk from place to place. This makes sense for me, but will it work for those who have less freedom in their work place. What rankles me is that the most people will only remember the headline and shrug off the report as unrealistic! They missed an opportunity. As Abba Eban once said about the Palestinians - 'they never miss an opportunity to miss an opportunity'. This frustrates me.

Posted by on September 07, 2002 09:49 AM | TrackBack




Comments:


I don't think it was exactly spin, more a clarification.

But I also agree that it seems possible it was meant to shock. Another case of intrended spin being spun at an angle, which may not be coherent but seems a common problem. I learned this the hard way when I accepted blame for something for something so people would move on from finger-pointing, without making it clear that I had been ordered to do it after thrice objecting - a later boss heard this, and fired me without reading five years of glowing job reports or asking me why I had messed up...

Certainly when I read the report on the recommendations, the impression I got was to go jogging for an hour, not to walk down from my ninth-floor digs and then an hour later back up, repeat as practical (which I will have to do next week, the elevator is going to be rebuilt again - third time in two years). And it would have been quite simple to fix before publishing: "a total of at least an hour a day". Instead, I got the feeling that I was listening to Richard Simmons again (sorry Mr. Simmons, but on the rare occasions I hear you I cringe). And have they explained the sugar business as well? Did they meane glucose/dextrose including that provided by chewing bread thoroughly, or just the kind I put in my coffee?

Once again I was almost persuaded that the medical profession is at least half nuts and to be approached only with caution. Thankfully there is still a preponderance of sanity, but sanity probably is not as newsworthy.

Posted by: John Anderson on September 7, 2002 01:36 PM






Post a Comment:

Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember your info?






It would be nice if everybody could find a doctor with half the common sense of this one. - Junkyardblog

An academic general internist comments on medical issues and the current state of medicine.

I reserve the right to be blatantly opinionated; you should take the right to criticize me!!



Try advanced site search!



The Sunday Issue of the Week continues. This feature will challenge me to carefully ponder an issue that I've referenced and commented on recently.

Current hot issues:

• Malpractice crisis
• Resident work hours
• Pharmaceutical industry
• Obesity and fitness